Ethics and Gifts

    The Standard

    A lawyer shall not solicit a substantial gift from a client, including a testamentary gift. Nor may a lawyer prepare an instrument giving the lawyer, or a person related to the lawyer, a substantial gift, unless the recipient is related to the client. ER 1.8(c).

    A lawyer shall not provide financial assistance to a client in connection with pending or contemplated litigation. The only exceptions are advancing court costs and litigation expenses, repayment of which may be contingent on the outcome, and paying those costs for an indigent client. ER 1.8(e).

    A lawyer shall not seek to influence a judge by means prohibited by law, ER 3.5(a), or knowingly assist a judge in conduct that violates the rules of judicial conduct, ER 8.4(f). What a judge may accept is governed by Rule 3.13 of the Arizona Code of Judicial Conduct.

    The Limitations

    ER 1.8(c) does not prohibit accepting an unsolicited gift. A simple gift is permitted. ER 1.8, Cmt. [4]. A more substantial gift may still create a personal-interest conflict under ER 1.7(a)(2), and the client may be able to void it for undue influence.

    The drafting prohibition cannot be cured by disclosure, consent or waiver. Under ER 1.8(k), it applies to every lawyer in the firm. When a substantial gift requires an instrument, the client should have the detached advice of a lawyer outside the firm. ER 1.8, Cmt. [5].

    Arizona has not adopted ABA Model Rule 1.8(e)(3), which allows modest gifts for basic living expenses to indigent pro bono clients.

    FAQs

    A client sent our firm a $400 case of wine for the holidays. Can we keep it?

    Yes. ER 1.8(c) prohibits soliciting a substantial gift and drafting the instrument that conveys one. It does not prohibit accepting an unsolicited gift, and Comment [4] specifically allows a holiday present.

    My elderly, recently widowed client wants me to add a $50,000 bequest to me in the trust amendment I’m already preparing. May I include it if it was her idea?

    No. Unless you are related to her, ER 1.8(c) prohibits you from preparing an instrument that gives you a substantial gift. No disclosure, consent or documentation cures it. Your partner can’t draft it either, because ER 1.8(k) imputes the prohibition to everyone in the firm.

    If she wants to make the gift, she should get the detached advice of a lawyer outside your firm. ER 1.8, Cmt. [5]; see Ariz. State Bar Ethics Op. 95-05 (accepting a substantial gift requires a different drafter and donative capacity).  Her age and recent loss also raise capacity questions under ER 1.14, and you could end up a witness in a will contest.

     

    Caveat: Even a gift handled ethically may not hold up. Under A.R.S. § 14-2712(E), an instrument is presumed to be the product of undue influence when its preparer is a principal beneficiary. The same presumption arises when someone in a confidential relationship actively procures the instrument and is a principal beneficiary. See In re Estate of Harber, 102 Ariz. 285 (1967); Mullin v. Brown, 210 Ariz. 545 (App. 2005).

    Last year, our holiday client baskets were a logistics headache. Can we send every current client a $100 Visa gift card instead?

    Proceed with caution. No rule bars a holiday gift to a client, and a modest basket unconnected to any outcome is fine. See Ariz. State Bar Ethics Op. 95-01 (de minimis gifts to clients). But a cash equivalent is different. For a client in pending/contemplated litigation, it can be financial assistance that ER 1.8(e) prohibits. The line is not the amount or your motive. It is what the client can do with the gift, and whether that client is in, or headed to, litigation. Non-cash gifts are the safer choice. If you do Visa gift cards, leave litigation clients off the list.

    My personal injury client can’t work because of the accident and can’t pay her utility bill. Can I give her the money? It would be a gift, not a loan.

    No. ER 1.8(e) permits two things: advancing court costs and litigation expenses, and paying those costs for an indigent client. Living expenses are neither, whether you call the money a loan or a gift. ER 1.8, Cmt. [8].

    Older State Bar opinions read in a humanitarian exception but they are advisory and do not bind the discipline system. A 2023 rule petition to add an exception modeled on ABA Model Rule 1.8(e)(3) was denied. In In re Virtue, No. SB-10-0078-D (2010), a lawyer was censured and placed on probation for paying $500 for a client’s car repair and $5,000 for a grave marker for the client’s son, conduct described as “although well intended.”

    You can still help. Point the client to nonrecourse third-party litigation funding, legal aid and social services, or, for senior clients, the Area Agency on Aging.

    Our new associate clerked for a judge through the summer and wants to drop off a holiday gift basket at chambers. Our firm has three matters pending before that judge. Is that ok?

    No. Suggest the associate send a card. Code of Judicial Conduct Rule 3.13 governs what a judge may accept and must report. Accepting something of value from a lawyer who has or will have matters before the judge is rarely appropriate. On the lawyer’s side, ER 3.5(a) prohibits seeking to influence a judge by means prohibited by law, and ER 8.4(f) prohibits knowingly assisting a judge in violating the Code.

    Judicial staff are not a safe harbor. Judicial Ethics Advisory Op. 90-05 concluded that holiday baskets, candy and plants sent by lawyers to a judge and chambers staff may not be accepted, and that the judge must see that staff comply. See also Op. 92-04 (book from a lawyer who frequently appears before the court). Both were decided under the former Canons, and the Judicial Ethics Advisory Committee notes that pre-2009 opinions may no longer be valid. But the caution they reflect still applies under Rule 3.13.

    Can our state bar section invite judges to its holiday reception?

    Generally, yes. Judges may attend holiday receptions hosted by lawyer groups if the event is not inappropriately extravagant. Judicial Ethics Advisory Op. 95-13 (decided under the former Canons); see Rule 3.13(B) (ordinary social hospitality). Judges may also accept nominal food and promotional items at conferences. Judicial Ethics Advisory Op. 09-01.

    I’m a prosecutor. A victim in a case I just resolved came by with a thank-you note and a $100 gift card. She is sincere and wants me to have it. Can I accept it?

    Keep the note and decline the gift card. Government lawyers have limits beyond the ERs: statutes (A.R.S. §§ 38-501 to -511), state policy (State of Arizona Accounting Manual Policy 5558, Accepting Gifts) and your office’s own gift policy. Public employment also brings heightened appearance concerns, so a gift that might pass in private practice can be flatly barred here.

    Her sincerity is not the issue. Decline warmly and explain that office rules don’t allow it. The same applies to a public defender offered a gift by a client.

    Not without clearing it under your office’s gift rules, and likely not at all. A complimentary pass from a regulated party is a thing of value from someone with business before your client. “Everyone in the industry goes” is not an exception. If attending serves your agency, the agency should at least pay the government rate.

    Not without clearing it under your office’s gift rules, and likely not at all. A complimentary pass from a regulated party is a thing of value from someone with business before your client. “Everyone in the industry goes” is not an exception. If attending serves your agency, the agency should at least pay the government rate.

    I’m not sure whether a gift crosses the line. Where can I get advice?

    The State Bar Ethics Hotline gives guidance on your own prospective conduct. To request a formal opinion, contact the Supreme Court’s Ethics Advisory Committee, whose opinions under Rule 42.1 are binding. Government lawyers should also check with their office’s policy and ethics counsel.

    This page is managed by Patricia Seguin

    suggestion, or problem with our website?